Most desserts and sweet goodies are not complete without a teaspoon or two of vanilla extract. As a stand-alone flavor, vanilla has a subtle aroma and mildly sweet flavor to tickle our taste buds in cakes and ice creams. Moreover, it is the unsung hero of many pastries and sweetened cold drinks, just as salt to savory dishes.
Vanilla enhances other flavors when used in chocolate-based and fruit-flavored recipes; hence, it is a staple ingredient for dessert lovers. To help you find the best vanilla extracts available, we have provided a list of recommendations and a buying guide, fact-checked and reviewed by registered nutritionist-dietitian Samantha Morales.
Quick List - Top Vanilla Extracts
Samantha began her career in clinical nutrition and weight management at a tertiary hospital in Manila, Philippines. Her practice allowed her to give nutrition counseling and plan modified diets for patients with medical conditions. Presently, she does private practice to focus on true holistic wellness - an approach that believes in aligning one's mind, body, and spiritual well-being.
Our recommendation articles are carefully researched and crafted by the mybest Philippines team of writers and editors. To stay true to our company’s mission and vision to help users’ selection process easier, we also collaborate with experts from various fields to ensure that our content stays factual and useful.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.
Table of Contents
Here are some key points to consider:
It's essential to check if the container label says vanilla extract to avoid switching it with vanilla flavoring because they are two different things. Vanilla extract has a stronger aroma than vanilla flavoring. It is because vanilla extract comes from whole vanilla beans immersed in water and ethyl alcohol or vodka.
On the other hand, the vanilla flavoring is a mixture of vanilla pod extract called vanillin and propylene glycol that mimics the authentic vanilla flavor only up to a certain degree. So, this one has a lighter scent and a milder taste.
Some vanilla extracts also have extra ingredients like syrup or other sweeteners to weaken the intense vanilla flavor. Remember, the purer the vanilla, the better. With this, look at the ingredients list - a vanilla extract is more refined if there are fewer ingredients.
While checking the product label, you also have to spot whether it says pure vanilla or imitation vanilla. Pure vanilla has a minimum of 35% alcohol and 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon. Another indicator of pure vanilla is the liquid's dark brown shade. If you want a genuine and sophisticated taste, then pure vanilla is the way to go.
Meanwhile, imitation vanilla is made from vanillin derived from wood pulp. It has water, synthetic alcohol, corn syrup, and caramel coloring, which explains its light brown hue or a colorless variety. Imitation vanilla is a good alternative if you're on a tight budget. Keep in mind, though, that it may leave a slightly bitter aftertaste.
The concentration of vanilla extract depends on the "number" of folds. Single-fold vanilla, which is the most available on the market today, has approximately 100 vanilla beans per gallon of alcohol. Following the pattern, the double-fold and triple-fold contain 200 and 300 vanilla beans, respectively, per gallon of alcohol.
The single-fold variant has the mildest scent and taste among the three. It is also the easiest to control when mixed in a dessert. However, remember that more folds mean that the aroma and flavor are stronger. When your vanilla extract is more concentrated, you only need a few drops to perfect the recipe.
Fun fact, vanilla extracts come from certain breeds of orchids. The use of vanilla is believed to have started in Mexico. Still, there are other variants of vanilla, each of which has distinct characteristics. Mexican vanilla beans contain a little bit of spicy, woody flavorーperfect for pumpkin cakes and apple pies.
On the other hand, Madagascar or Bourbon vanilla beans are the most commonly available variant. They have the traditional vanilla flavor, with a rich and creamy taste, ideal for any recipe. Meanwhile, Tahiti's vanilla beans are fruity in taste.
In contrast, the Indonesian vanilla beans have a smoky flavor and an intense sweetness, perfect for chocolate-based creations. It all boils down to the recipe and personal preferences. You can also buy them all to try and compare.
Vanilla extract does not quickly expire. Its shelf life is pretty long, but buying vanilla extract in a glass bottle is preferred to lessen the chances of the aroma and flavor waning over time. It is much better if it's stored in a dark-colored bottle, like amber, because vanilla beans should not be exposed to too much light.
Also, consider the net weight and expiration dates of the product. Take a smaller size if you are not going to frequently use it to avoid spoilage. But if you are preparing in large quantities, whether for a food business or party, a bigger bottle of vanilla extract is a wise choice.
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Key features | |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Simply Organic Pure Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Whip Guilt-Free Desserts With This 100% Organic Vanilla | |
2 | The Vanilla Company Finest Organic Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Get Stronger Flavor With Double-Fold Vanilla | |
3 | Watkins Pure Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Create Extra Rich Confections With This Award-Winning Product | |
4 | Flavorganics Organic Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Secret Weapon for Healthy Sweet Snacks | |
5 | McCormick Vanilla Flavor | ![]() | Bourbon Vanilla Flavor From a Trusted Brand | |
6 | Bakersfield Pure Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Mexican Beans-Derived Vanilla Extract for Baked Recipes and Dulce Treats | |
7 | Frontier Co-op Organic Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Organic Vanilla Extract With Versatile Uses | |
8 | Purely Bahay Pure Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Uses Locally Brewed Vanilla Beans and Has a Smooth and Velvety Finish | |
9 | Grandeur Vanilla Extract | ![]() | Rich Vanilla Extract That Won’t Break the Bank | |
10 | Orion Vanilla Food Flavoring | ![]() | Affordable Vanilla Flavor for Pinoy-Style Refreshments |
Getting the top spot in this list is Simply Organic's Pure Vanilla Extract. This product is certified to have no GMO, no artificial color, and flavor, so you know you're only getting the good stuff. Its aroma is on the mild side, with a mellow sweetness and a rich, creamy texture. It also has a deep amber color.
Each bean is carefully blanched and cured with organic alcohol, and a little water to extract and carry the flavorーit has no sugar and preservatives added. With this, you can create guilt-free and organic cakes, pastries, and ice cream. It's also a huge plus that the company is partnering with small-scale vanilla farmers from Madagascar.
Each bottle of The Vanilla Company's Organic Vanilla Extract contains a double-fold vanilla extract, which means you only need a few drops to pull off a delightful recipe. Double-fold vanilla extracts possess a more concentrated and stronger flavor, giving your recipes a richer taste.
What's more exciting is that it is available in three flavor choices that you can add to your cart. The creamy Bourbon variant has subtle notes of chocolate flavor- perfect for sundaes, mousses, and tiramisu. The Madagascar variant has the classic and velvety texture for coffee drinks and goodies, while you can use fruity Tahitian for tropical pies.
The brand Watkins may not ring a bell to most Pinoy home cooks, but this award-winning brand has been included in this list because of its great feedback from international reviews. Made from the highest quality Madagascar Bourbon vanilla beans, it can surely impart a rich flavor to a wide range of dishes, confections, and even refreshments.
Whether you're making french toasts or whipping up milkshakes, you can be assured that this vanilla extract can make them sweeter, creamier, and extra rich! Apart from that, it's a good pick for those with particular sensitivities, as it's gluten-free, Non-GMO, Kosher-compliant, and contains no artificial flavors and colors.
Flavorganics' Organic Vanilla Extract is made from the finest vanilla beans. With just a spoonful, it can add so much difference to your pancakes and other baked treats. You can also use it for your torched crème brûlée and dark chocolate chip cookies.
It is a gluten-free and non-GMO product, perfect for those with gluten sensitivities who can't give up desserts. With that said, it can be the ideal vanilla extract for creating healthy sweet snacks that your family and friends will love. And with its amber glass bottle, you can also be assured that its flavor is well-preserved!
You can never leave this one out when it comes to excellent vanilla flavorings. Manufactured by a credible brand of food coloring, spices, and flavors, the McCormick vanilla flavor offers a bourbon fragrance and taste that will make your baked treats and cool drinks more flavorful!
Thanks to the powerful combination of vanillin and extractives from cocoa and tea, this vanilla flavor has a creamy and mild chocolatey flavor. It also has a subtle sweetness, and it possesses an amber shade due to the corn syrup and caramel coloring.
This product is one of Pinoys' go-to for making sago't gulaman. You can also use it to make desserts, like vanilla butter cake and double-dutch ice cream from scratch. It can also be a good ingredient for merienda favorites, such as puto, maja blanca, and leche flan.
Bakersfield's Pure Vanilla Extract features Mexican vanilla beans with a woody flavor, making it the perfect addition to a wide range of confectionaries. You can use it to make sweet or dulce pies and cakes with citrus fruits or vineyard vegetables as the main ingredients.
You can also mix this extract to add spice and enhance the fruity flavors of lemon meringue, pumpkin, and carrot cake. It also works fine with banana loaves and for flavoring drinks! Furthermore, you'll love that it is all-natural with extractives coming from real vanilla beans.
Frontier Co-op's Vanilla Extract is another great pick if you are looking for an organic option that is free of synthetic ingredients. Crafted with Bourbon vanilla beans, this extract can bring out the fullest flavors in your creations. The only downside is that its price is leaning on the more expensive side.
But don't fret, as you'll get a buttery smooth, extra-sweet flavor complemented by subtle floral notes that will surely harmonize well with your dessert and beverage creations. Since it also has no added sugar, you can use it for sauces and savory recipes that call for vanilla extract!
Want to support local brands? Purely Bahay's vanilla extract is what you're looking for! The vanilla beans used for this are grade-B quality and imported from Madagascar, but they are closer to home because they are brewed and extracted here in the Philippines. As expected from a Madagascar vanilla, it has a smooth, velvety texture with a creamy flavor.
Besides cakes, you can use this vanilla extract for lattes, smoothies, and cocktails. You can also add it to various Filipino cold drinks and desserts, such as sago't gulaman, saba con yelo, and ice scramble. Another great thing about it is that it has no preservatives, yet it does not expire as long as you keep it in a cool, dry place.
Although artificial, this vanilla extract by Grandeur exudes a rich vanilla taste that can provide flavor to bread, cookies, and other baked goods. This is why it has garnered thousands of positive reviews from home bakers and professional bakers alike.
According to some of them, it has a delightful vanilla whiff that you can smell just upon opening its bottle. Another edge of this product is its cost-efficiency. It is a great value-for-money solution to all your baking needs since you can get an ample amount of quality vanilla extract for a budget price!
For sure, most of us have enjoyed Pinoy-style cold drinks called samalamig from food stalls or even made one ourselves. Orion is a great choice for those who sell or simply make sagot'gulaman at home since it's very affordable. Its quality is not compromised- you won't feel any sugar granules in your mouth.
And aside from using it for refreshments, you can add this vanilla extract to your guinatang mais and bilu-bilo or cold confections such as ice candies or homemade sorbetes. Plus, you can use this in baking bread and pastries in large quantities, ideal for starting a food business
Below are some of the most asked questions on the web answered by mybest team.
No, vanilla extract is a natural product, while vanilla essence is synthetic. Vanilla extract also provides a more robust flavor than essence. Thus, it is best used for cooking. On the other hand, vanilla essence is suitable for baked pastries that don’t need a strong vanilla punch.
Yes, when consumed in large doses. After all, vanilla extract is 70 proof, which means it has an alcohol level of 35% ABV, just a little less than a bottle of vodka. But if you're worried about getting intoxicated when you add it to your baked goods, it is less likely since most recipes only call for just a few drops of this extract.
Yes. Depending on your recipe, you may use vanilla powder, vanilla paste, maple syrup, honey, bourbon, or almond extract to substitute vanilla extracts. Just make sure to use the correct ratio since their concentration levels may vary from one another.
Trying to experiment in the kitchen by using different flavors and seasonings? Check out the articles below to know more about different ingredients for enhancing the flavors of your recipes. We've put together helpful buying guides and curated a list of product recommendations, so shopping online will be easier!
Author: Roel Pillas Malubay
Re-editor: R. Victoriano
Our buying guide was carefully researched and crafted by the mybest team of writers and editors, in collaboration with the expert featured in this article. We used the buying guide as a basis for choosing and ranking the product recommendations, and we looked at reviews and ratings from different E-commerce sites like Lazada, Shopee, and more.
No. 1: Simply Organic|Pure Vanilla Extract
No. 2: The Vanilla Company|Finest Organic Vanilla Extract
No. 3: Watkins|Pure Vanilla Extract
No. 4: Flavorganics|Organic Vanilla Extract
No. 5: McCormick|Vanilla Flavor
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Beauty
Health
Household goods
PCs and laptops
Home appliances and electronics
Cameras
Food and drinks
Kitchen supplies
Clothing
Shoes
Accessories
Mom and baby
Interior and furniture
Hobbies
Outdoor
DIY and tools
Sports and fitness
Pets
Books, CDs, and DVDs
Games
Cars and motorcycles
Gifts
Home improvement and tools
Smartphones and tablets
Banking and finance
Insurance
Audio
Smartphone applications
Others