Putting on eyeliner might be one of the hardest things to learn and master when doing your makeup. Sometimes, even experienced makeup artists still struggle to keep the wings of their eyeliners even! The type of eyeliner you will use, whether it is a gel, liquid, or pencil will also depend on the kind of look you are going for.
What should you consider when buying an eyeliner? What are the differences between gel, pencil, and liquid eyeliners? What type of eyeliner is easy to use? Are they beginner-friendly? And which eyeliner is long-lasting? Don’t worry! We did all the research for you! We even listed down a few of our favorite items in our Top 10 list. We also invited Elaine Ganuelas, a beauty professional, to share some of her tips and insights. Keep on reading to find out more!
Quick List - Top Eyeliners
Elaine Ganuelas has been living and breathing the life of all things beauty since childhood. What once started as her passion became her career in 2006. Now she does makeup, hairstyling, image consultation (yes, makeovers), personal shopping, consumer research, and reviews.
Our recommendation articles are carefully researched and crafted by the mybest Philippines team of writers and editors. To stay true to our company’s mission and vision to help users’ selection process easier, we also collaborate with experts from various fields to ensure that our content stays factual and useful.
The expert oversees the Buying Guide only, and does not determine the products and services featured.
Table of Contents
Every mybest article is crafted with hours of in-depth research and interviews with experts. Each month, we are continually expanding our database of products based on our research. By emphasizing user insight and reliable information, we deliver trustworthy content to readers.
To pick a good eyeliner and level up your eye makeup game, there are aspects you should take into account: the type of eyeliner suited for you, the features you should look for, as well as the shades you should go for. Read on to find out more about them below:
Putting on eyeliner could be quite tricky if you're a beginner, so the best eyeliner is one that you'll be comfortable using. Below, we'll introduce the different types of eyeliners and what they're best for.
To add to the information above, pencil eyeliners are the most sanitary type and usually come in an array of colors!
Gel liners are kind of the median in the category. They are great for lining the waterline since they don't smudge easily. They can also mimic the precise look of liquid liners without difficulty. Simply choose a brush that you can be comfortable with to create thin or thick lines. And for those who are still beginners at using eyeliners, there are gel liners that come in pencil types, making the application process even easier.
When it comes to liquid eyeliners, you have two options: dip pot and pen. Their formulas are more or less the same, and there's a slight difference in application. For dip pots, you'll have to dip the brush to get some product, while pens offer a more straightforward application.
You also have the option between brush type and felt-tip type. The brush type is the best choice if you want to get a precise and pointy flick, but it requires careful pressure control when applying. Meanwhile, felt tips feel more like using a pencil liner, but it's not as easy to maneuver. Regardless of your choice, both types of liquid eyeliner offer smooth application.
If you have difficulty using liquid liners, you can try the "connect the dots" method. This makes it easier to create even and straight lines as opposed to creating a line in one go.
You definitely don't want your eyeliner running down your face by the end of the day, especially in the Philippines where sweating can mess it up. Look for an eyeliner that's waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweat-proof to make it last longer.
With one like that, you won't have to worry about your eyeliner melting away as you go about your day. But if you're still learning and want more flexibility for fixing mistakes, a non-waterproof eyeliner might be a better fit.
Tip: liners labeled "gel liners" are usually waterproof and smudge-proof after they are set. If you doubt if your liner can last, lightly "set" the line you've drawn with a powder shadow of the same color.
In addition to the standard black eyeliner, there is a wide array of colored eyeliners you can use to add variety and experiment with for your eye makeup. Explore vibrant hues, soft pastels, or even glamorous metallic shades to elevate your overall look. Let your creativity shine by embracing the diverse range of colors available.
If you have black or brown eyes, you can make your eyes stand out more by using colors like bronze, copper, and deep plum. For those with hazel eyes, you can use rich earth tones or green tones to bring out the different shades in your eyes. However, if you want to keep it simple, you may opt for classics like black, brown, and navy-colored eyeliners.
Don't be afraid to get ideas from beauty tutorials, makeup artists, or other Filipinos with similar eye colors. By choosing the right eyeliner colors, you can easily create stunning looks that show off your eye color and express your individuality.
If you want to experiment with shades or finishes, those that have shimmer or metallics like bronze, gold, champagne, copper, or rose gold are great options. You can also try khaki or olive greens, navy, or other earth tones if you want something more subtle.
Decided to make a bold statement with colorful eyeliners? Keep the look grounded by opting for neutral eyeshadows and a neutral lip color.
Products | Image | Click to purchase | Key features | Details | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Application Type | Waterproof | Long-Lasting | No. of Available Shades | Net Weight | |||||
1 | Vice Cosmetics On The Daily Lasting Liners | ![]() | Bold, Precise, and Smudge-Resistant Definition | Gel | 5 | 0.35 mL | |||
2 | Ever Bilena Color Pencil | ![]() | Effortless Definition That Enhances Your Natural Look | Pencil | 2 | unknown | |||
3 | Issy Gel Pencil Extreme | ![]() | Long-Wear Gel Liner To Perfect Bold, Vibrant Eyes | Gel | 8 | 21 mL | |||
4 | BLK Cosmetics Fresh Waterproof Gel Liner | ![]() | Velvety Gel Liner for Clean, Smudge-Free Eye Definition | Gel | 7 | 0.8 mL | |||
5 | Careline Graph-Ink Liner | ![]() | Waterproof Precision Eyeliner and Bold, All-Day Sharpness | Liquid/Pen | 1 | 0.55 mL | |||
6 | Maybelline Tattoo Liquid Pen Eyeliner | ![]() | Bold, Long-Lasting Liquid Pen Liner for Striking Looks | Liquid/Pen | 1 | unknown | |||
7 | GRWM Cosmetics Super Fine Liner Duo | ![]() | Dual-Ended Waterproof Liner, Limitless Eye Expressions | Liquid/Pen | 3 | unknown | |||
8 | ETUDE House Proof 10 Gel Pencil | ![]() | Stay Sharp and Confident with Smudge-Proof, All-Day Precision | Gel | 4 | 0.3 mL | |||
9 | In2it Eyeliner Pen Waterproof | ![]() | Define Boldly, Last Fearlessly, Smudge Never | Liquid/Pen | 3 | 1 mL | |||
10 | CLIO Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner | ![]() | Effortless Precision for All-Day Confidence | Pencil | 7 | 0.14 mL |
Users love the quality and report that this long-lasting eyeliner does not irritate their eyes, making it comfortable for daily use. Many with oily skin appreciate its impressive staying power that lasts throughout the day without smudging. However, some users mention that when used as an under eyeliner, it tends to smudge, so it may not be ideal for that specific application.
Application Type | Gel |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 5 |
Net Weight | 0.35 mL |
Users find this pencil easy to use with a smooth, creamy texture that glides on effortlessly. It is praised for being smudge-proof under normal conditions and great for defining eyebrows and creating precise lines on eyelids. Many appreciate its affordable price for a quality product that's beginner-friendly.
Application Type | Pencil |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 2 |
Net Weight | unknown |
Users find the built-in buffer brush useful for blending the gel pencil to create soft, smoky effects easily. They appreciate the variety of shades available, highlighting it as perfect for versatile looks, especially smokey eyes. The liner is praised for being long-wearing, waterproof, and budge-proof, holding up well throughout the day even in humid conditions.
Application Type | Gel |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 8 |
Net Weight | 21 mL |
Users love how suitable this liner is for sensitive eyes, finding it gentle without irritation. They frequently praise its rich, pigmented color that pops instantly and is wearable on all complexions. Many highlight that it lasts for hours without smudging, even through sweat and tears, making it reliable for all-day wear.
Application Type | Gel |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 7 |
Net Weight | 0.8 mL |
Users praise this eyeliner for its smooth and even application that glides on without tugging or scratching, making it ideal for creating sharp winged looks. Its highly pigmented true black ink delivers bold definition and holds well without drying out even after multiple uses. Many appreciate its excellent waterproof and smudge-proof formula that ensures long-lasting wear throughout the day without fading or smudging, especially on oily lids. But overall it offers great value for money with reliable performance and comfort.
Application Type | Liquid/Pen |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 1 |
Net Weight | 0.55 mL |
Users find this long-lasting eyeliner dries quickly without transferring onto the eyelids, allowing them to continue their makeup routine without smudges. Many praise its professional-looking finish and intense black pigment that adds striking definition. It lives up to its waterproof claim, with reviews noting it withstands rubbing after setting and holds up well in sweat and humidity. The thin applicator is highlighted for ease of use and precise application, making it suitable even for less experienced users.
Application Type | Liquid/Pen |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 1 |
Net Weight | unknown |
Users highlight the super slim and sharp tip, which allows for incredibly precise application—even for the thinnest, most detailed lines. Many find it easy to use, praising the dual tips for versatility in creating both fine and dramatic looks. The eyeliner is also noted for its very long-lasting, smudge-resistant formula that stays put throughout the day.
Application Type | Liquid/Pen |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 3 |
Net Weight | unknown |
Users love the intense pigmentation that gives a bold, striking look perfect for defined eye makeup. The soft tip allows for easy, smooth application without tugging, making it especially beginner-friendly compared to liquid liners. This gel pencil glides on effortlessly, allowing quick, precise drawing of sharp and clear lines. Many appreciate the long-lasting, waterproof formula that withstands water and oil, keeping the eyeliner neat all day with minimal smudging.
Application Type | Gel |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 4 |
Net Weight | 0.3 mL |
Users consistently praise the eyeliner for its reliable waterproof and smudge-proof performance. Many consider it the best among other brands they have tried due to its strong pigmentation and smooth application. The black shade is frequently highlighted for its rich, intense color that enhances eye definition effectively.
Application Type | Liquid/Pen |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 3 |
Net Weight | 1 mL |
This long-lasting eyeliner doesn’t budge once dry, but users note it requires a few moments to set to avoid smudging during application. The smooth and creamy texture allows effortless, precise application without tugging. It delivers intense, bold color payoff that stays vibrant throughout the day. Many users liked it so much they repurchased it, appreciating its reliable waterproof and smudge-proof performance.
Application Type | Pencil |
---|---|
Waterproof | |
Long-Lasting | |
No. of Available Shades | 7 |
Net Weight | 0.14 mL |
Below are some of the most asked questions on the web answered by Elaine Ganuelas.
There are two areas you could apply eyelinerーinner lash line or waterline and the outer lash line, depending on the look you want to achieve. However, in terms of eye safety, doctors recommend applying it on the outer lash line.
This is because eyeliner could migrate into your eyes, which could cause irritation, especially for those who have sensitive skin or wear contacts. Should you really want to achieve a look with tightlining or lining the waterline, spray alcohol, sanitizer, or disinfectant on the pencil, wipe with tissue then proceed with lining,
The countdown of makeup’s shelf life begins on the day you first use it. You can also refer to the suggested expiry date printed on the packaging. There should be an illustration of a small opened pot with numbers and a letter “M,” which stands for months. So, if it says 6M, you’ll know it expires 6 months after opening.
That said, expiration dates also vary depending on the type of eyeliner. For instance, pencil eyeliners can last for 1-2 years, especially if you sharpen them, making them less likely to harbor bacteria. Liquid eyeliners last for 3-4 months as the brush is prone to bacteria. And gel liners are only good for 2 months because the pot easily traps dirt.
To make the product last even longer, it is recommended to sanitize the product before and after use.
Having a steady hand is helpful but rare. You can reduce the shaking or wobbling by resting your elbows on a table while applying the liner. For putting eyeliner really close to the lash line or tightlining upper lids, look down and hold a mirror from that angle as you apply the liner.
Here are some more makeup recommendations to help you experiment and complete your makeup collection!
Author: Rie Niijima
Re-editor: J. Cuizon
Our buying guide was carefully researched and crafted by the mybest team of writers and editors, in collaboration with the expert featured in this article. We used the buying guide as a basis for choosing and ranking the product recommendations, and we looked at reviews and ratings from different E-commerce sites like Lazada, Shopee, and more.
No. 1: Vice Cosmetics|On The Daily Lasting Liners
No. 2: Ever Bilena|Color Pencil
No. 3: Issy|Gel Pencil Extreme
No. 4: BLK Cosmetics|Fresh Waterproof Gel Liner
No. 5: Careline|Graph-Ink Liner
View Full RankingThe descriptions of each product are referenced from content available on manufacturer, brand, and e-commerce sites.
Beauty
Health
Household goods
PCs and laptops
Home appliances and electronics
Cameras
Food and drinks
Kitchen supplies
Clothing
Shoes
Accessories
Mom and baby
Interior and furniture
Hobbies
Outdoor
DIY and tools
Sports and fitness
Pets
Books, CDs, and DVDs
Games
Cars and motorcycles
Gifts
Home improvement and tools
Smartphones and tablets
Banking and finance
Insurance
Audio
Smartphone applications
Others